1. Introduction
Body is a key factor showing human existence. Each person has different ways of thinking
because they are different in both physical and mental conditions. There are many scholars in
different fields of study discussing human body, especially philosophers such as Schopenhauer,
Nietzsche, Merleau – Ponty, John O'Neill and Foucault. Most of them highly evaluated the role of
body in the existence of people and society. A part of existential philosophy is human position
which describes human existence and its abilities.
Schopenhauer is regarded as one of the first philosophers who highly evaluated the body’s
role in people’s survival. He claimed that the body was a bridge connecting human minds and the
world, and people’s thoughts were actualized through their actions. In other words, our minds
affected this universe through our bodies and actions. Thus, physical activities are very important.
Nietzsche put the body in the center of philosophy with the idea that it’s necessary to consider the
body as a standard to evaluate human senses. In his opinion, the world belongs to human senses
and their creation because our senses had never cheated us. Therefore, the word and the body
closely related to each other. This means that the world is the description and product of the body,
determination and power. John O’neil in the book named Five forms of body also said that the
body has five forms, which are the body in the universe, in the society, in the politics, in the
consumer’s market and in medicine. On one hand, Foucault supposed that the body played an
important role in social life as means of historical expression and operated place of power and
speech. Thus, it is closely linked to sexuality, politics and life. In the Phenomenology of
Perception, Merleau-Ponty argued that all higher functions of consciousness, such as knowledge
and determination, were derived from and dependent on the sensation of flesh and the reflection of
subject. From this point of view, he asserted that the body was the common mean for people to
lead the world. The nature of the body is a "space of expression".
8 trang |
Chia sẻ: thanhle95 | Lượt xem: 419 | Lượt tải: 0
Bạn đang xem nội dung tài liệu The study of human body in Nguyen Duy’s poetry, để tải tài liệu về máy bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
29
HNUE JOURNAL OF SCIENCE DOI: 10.18173/2354-1067.2018-0046
Social Sciences, 2018, Volume 63, Issue 7, pp. 29-36
This paper is available online at
THE STUDY OF HUMAN BODY IN NGUYEN DUY’S POETRY
Chung Thi Thuy
Hong Duc University, Thanh Hoa
Abstract. Human body is the basement for people’s existence. All human consciousness
seems to be resulted from their body. It is regarded as a subject that involved in all human
activities and created thoughts as well as human values. Although through Nguyen Duy’s
writing career, the poet didn’t intend to use body’s language as one of means of expression.
However, the body marked a deep impression in his poetry showing the fundaments of his
ideas and feelings of the subject. The language of the body in his poems tended to point out
some important issues such as the origin of the body, the body in wars, and the body in
poverty.
Key words: Human body, Nguyen Duy’s poetry.
1. Introduction
Body is a key factor showing human existence. Each person has different ways of thinking
because they are different in both physical and mental conditions. There are many scholars in
different fields of study discussing human body, especially philosophers such as Schopenhauer,
Nietzsche, Merleau – Ponty, John O'Neill and Foucault. Most of them highly evaluated the role of
body in the existence of people and society. A part of existential philosophy is human position
which describes human existence and its abilities.
Schopenhauer is regarded as one of the first philosophers who highly evaluated the body’s
role in people’s survival. He claimed that the body was a bridge connecting human minds and the
world, and people’s thoughts were actualized through their actions. In other words, our minds
affected this universe through our bodies and actions. Thus, physical activities are very important.
Nietzsche put the body in the center of philosophy with the idea that it’s necessary to consider the
body as a standard to evaluate human senses. In his opinion, the world belongs to human senses
and their creation because our senses had never cheated us. Therefore, the word and the body
closely related to each other. This means that the world is the description and product of the body,
determination and power. John O’neil in the book named Five forms of body also said that the
body has five forms, which are the body in the universe, in the society, in the politics, in the
consumer’s market and in medicine. On one hand, Foucault supposed that the body played an
important role in social life as means of historical expression and operated place of power and
speech. Thus, it is closely linked to sexuality, politics and life. In the Phenomenology of
Perception, Merleau-Ponty argued that all higher functions of consciousness, such as knowledge
and determination, were derived from and dependent on the sensation of flesh and the reflection of
subject. From this point of view, he asserted that the body was the common mean for people to
lead the world. The nature of the body is a "space of expression".
Received January 10, 2018. Accepted July 21, 2018.
Contact Chung Thi Thuy, e-mail address: chungthuy362@gmail.com
Chung Thi Thuy
30
From the view of existentialism and phenomenology, it’s impossible for all human separate
their brain from their flesh in doing activities. Human is paid much attention by literature
including poetry. Thus, many kinds of human activities and expression are interesting subjects of
literary works.
Growing up in the war against the American Empire, Nguyen Duy started writing poems
quite early. The unhappiness of his private life and the witness of many great national historical
events implies many emotions, thinking and the reflection of human life, the meaning of human
existence and social position in his poetry. Nguyen Duy's composition has caught much interest
from critics and researchers, so the some aspects of human body in his works has been
investigated. The most outstanding is the poem named: “The sense of humor in Nguyen Duy’s
poetry” in which human body was shown in a joking and sensitive way when it faced the changes
and impression of the body. The poet wrote as it is the feeling started at young ages: “One day, I
saw my friend shy/ Covering the growing breast/ I was infatuated to see pink cheeks”, so “Feeling
itchy in the soul” cited in the poem White dress and pink cheeks. After that, the teaser in Nguyen
Duy’s poems became various: “Don’t skimp the young body/ Remember to share beauty with me”
(Strokes and shapes). Even the images of female in modern countries were reflected in Nguyen
Duy’s poems: “I change myself into the warm sun/ Cover the trembling skin welcoming the sun”
(A little Northern Europe) [4]. In the writing: “Nguyen Duy- the poet of ordinary people”, Chu
Van Son wrote that the bodies of “various human lives in the present” which are disable,
hard-working and miserable. These bodies are ugly, but Nguyen Duy discovered their hidden
beauty. They’re the old Cham hunch backed, the old man hit crying on the platform, the
woman was found out lying under the bridge, the prostitute welcoming the new year’s Eve
under the tree, the street child with disable legs under the roof hearing fireworks, the man
with wooden crutches sitting by the river missing the homeland: “the lives at the beginning of
the streets and those at the end of markets/ Where to go when the new year comes”. They are
all like “pebbles and mud under the water”, “storks wandering by the seashores”, “bored
with tiring streets”, the whole life is attached to “footsteps” - “The footsteps of Giao Chi
residents”. However, they carry not only the suffering of ordinary people but also their
beauty [6]. In Characteristics of Nguyen Duy's poetry of Nguyen Lam Dien, the human body in
Nguyen Duy’s poems is mentioned in many aspects praising the beauty of Vietnamese people in
daily activities such as painting walls, sweeping streets, sewing clothes, and moving stones. The
beauty is mainly shown throughout the image of hands. In the writing: “The country life in
Nguyen Duy’s alexandrine”, the body of Vietnamese people is mentioned through the image of
poor farmers working hard all year around, but this doesn’t cause pessimistic feelings or boredom.
On the other hand, it can be seen behind the hard work is “the fervent vitality, the benevolent soul
and the beautiful nature of the poor people” [8]. Duong Ky Anh in “Nguyen Duy poet: “The time
gone, the fields faded””, the body in this work is expressed through real people’s lives and the
source of Nguyen Duy poetry. They are grandparents, mothers and wives. The obsession about the
grandmother is linked to the scene of walking 14 kilometers to sell green tea on naked feet. They
may be lack of the knowledge of letters, but they are good at remembering many folks and fairy
tales as well as jokes. The image of the mother is supposed to derive from that treasure of
folklores "dyed black teeth, skirt, usually lying on the hammock singing lullabies for me".
Although the issue of body in Nguyen Duy’s poems has been mentioned in many works, none of
them brings a systematical study. Thus, with this article, we would like to bring a new perspective,
selective inheritance of previous researches to contribute a different interpretation in a broader
view on Nguyen Duy’s poetry career.
The study of human body in Nguyen Duy’s poetry
31
2. Content
In Nguyen Duy’s poems, the body has left a deep impression on readers because this is
realistic, not romantic. He brings the reflection of life with daily common worries from all kinds
of people. The body of each human life is truly and meticulously portrayed in his poems including
real lives, people’s fates and scenes as painted on the pages. In each situation of different lives,
Nguyen Duy portrayed a different body that left the unforgettable obsession and thought in the
heart of readers.
2.1. The origin of the body
Every human was born with different bodies by different ancestors in a certain cultural
environment. It’s a truth which is so obvious that most of us pay little attention. However, for
Nguyen Duy, this is the greatest thing which impressed his mind, so he devoted all his life to
research it. He wanted to “show himself and his own origin as well as the source of his poetry” [6].
In Nguyen Duy's poems, each body of human life carries the image of himself. Furthermore, the
ego of the poet was also represented throughout many other bodies in his life.
It can be said that the source of flesh in Nguyen Duy poetry is originally shown as the source
of nature and the homeland’s cultural atmosphere. The nature with its climate, environment, and
stratigraphy, has imprinted on the body of every person. Sometimes, the person uses his or her
body to feel the nature and their land on their own way. For him, the homeland is the root with all
simple and familiar things, which left traces on each person’s body. In the poem named The
childhood, he said: “people in mountainous areas carried the trace of springs and trees while
those in coastal areas carried the trace of some waves and wind; city residents carried the trace
of streets while those in the countryside carried the trace of fields and gardens”. This means that
people born in different living environments own distinctive bodies, that are full of features in
these areas. Continuously leaves traces on human bodies’ time. Day by day, the bodies grows up
and changes, but for Nguyen Duy – the poet, they are always full of traces of nature and their
homeland’s culture, which are kept during their lifetime. Sometimes, people misunderstand that
their childhood was over and could never be brought back, but the body has been always
surviving regardless of the time gone, carrying the trace of the homeland which we are unable to
deny or change: “The tracewas engraved in the bones/ the childhood can’t be exchanged/ we
think about our origin all life/ there is a homeland in our footsteps and voice”. The origin
potentially hid each person's body in any place at any time even when the body gets older or
weaker. The poet said: “Any childhood will appear/ Although we get older”. This means that
despite human ages, the childhood can be back. The poem namely The Len ferry is a good
example for this simple discovery. The poem is a memory of emotional childhood, all events are
like something happened yesterday. In a natural way, the poet tells the readers about naughty
games of his childhood’s home such as: going to the village’s entrance for fishing, following the
grandmother to the local market, catching birds in Buddha’s ears, and stealing fruits in Tran
pagoda. Nguyen Duy named drains, markets, pagodas in a natural way with many memories.
Without being closed to his homeland’s natural and cultural environment, how could he tell in
such emotional way? The childhood’s memories of the romantic subject continue to run in the
flow of emotions according to his recollections: “In my childhood I visited Cay Thi Temple/
Going on barefoot to see Song Temple Festival at night/ the flavor of white tuberoses mixed with
incense smoke was really fragrant/ melodies accompanied the groggy shadow of fortune tellers”
cited in The Len Ferry. The human tries to take advantage of senses to feel both the natural and
cultural environment of his hometown. It is the feeling of the feet touching the homeland which is
too rough that it leaves traces on his body. That memory has followed him throughout his life.
Long time has gone, however, many memories in the romantic subject’s mind about all things
Chung Thi Thuy
32
were felt by his tongue and eyes such as: “white tuberoses mixed with incense smoke” and
“melodies accompanied the groggy shadow of fortune tellers”. Nguyen Duy seems to live in the
space of his native culture with all his senses that capture and preserve such miraculous things.
The river of his hometown has brought many unforgettable memories deep in the poet’s mind,
which were felt by touching. He said: “Aged 10 I swam in the water flowing/ Sunbathing on this
side and bathing on the other side”. Having grown up, he remained the feeling of swimming and
bathing in the river. Perhaps with an innocent and carefree character, the romantic subject "I" has
not yet felt the spirituality that the homeland’s nature offers, so he lived with customs and original
instincts. But that memory is always fresh when “I” grow and realize that it is the source of the
body, the "trace of fields and gardens" that has followed the poet year by year. For Nguyen Duy,
the hometown leaves traces on the body from the first touch of the flesh on the land, the exposure
to the river and the sunshine of the shore. Although away from home for years, "I" still remember
the source of my birth: "From that river/ I left/ drops from the source of the sea/ the wind from Ma
River cools all my life” cited in The Mother River. The poet does not only regard the river as the
origin of the body of the subject “I” but he is also willing to be a drop of that river could join into
the large ocean. In addition to the traces of the river, there are some traces of a straight paddy field
with all kinds of creatures offered by the nature: “In my childhood the field was boundless/ With
grass, rice and wild plants/ With white snail shells and dry furrows/ With muddy rice field with
crab footprints/ My childhood was purely white with stork wings/ blackbirds with yellow beaks
and hummingbirds with red tails/ The halcyon shot blue arrows/ The magpie-robin wakened the
morning” quoted in The childhood. Regardless of moving to any places, the subject always
remembers his own original hometown with its rustic features: “I miss myself/ a dusty homeland”.
It can be seen that the homeland’s nature and culture are the original sources of the appearance of
body leaving traces on all human daily activities in Nguyen Duy’s poetry.
Beside the source of nature is the source of flesh - the source of all human bodies. If the
origin of the hometown’s natural and cultural atmosphere brings a common cultural identity to the
body, the origin of the blood and the flesh as the first source of physical existence forms the soul
of Nguyen Duy’s poems. The mother’s milk and lullabies are sweet streams nurturing the body
and inspiring the soul of his poetry: “The mother sang ethics in life/ her milk raised the flesh, but
her lullabies inspired the soul/ the grandmother sang lullabies to her and she sang them to me/ If
children would memorize it”. The mother did not only create the body of children but also
sacrifice all her life to their growth with health and great ideals. The child missed the dead mother
in the sacred and dreamful space and the scent of tuberose flowers. In that space, the mother
seemed to continue with the worries of daily life. In another case, in the child's mind, the image of
mother with anxiety and hard work always exists in this world: “Feeling sad with the scent of
tuberose at night/ The incense smoke leads the way to the nirvana/incense ashes are hidden
behind incense sticks/the mother is still on Earth”. The image of mother appeared with hard-
working personality and simple lifestyles in the child’s boundless love: “My mother doesn’t have
pink blouses/ Wearing conical hats instead of the Quai Thao/ Confused with much work/ Mud-
dyed dresses and brown shirts during four seasons” quoted in the poem named Sad to miss the
past mother. The poor and miserable mother in the girlhood didn’t have pink blouses or the Quai
Thao hat. She wore conical hats and mud-died clothes. The more the child away from the
homeland, the more past was recalled the missing of his dead mother with her great sacrifice and
boundless love for children. The mother's nourishment is shown in every gesture: “Looking back
to the homeland/ my soul- lied my mother on wet land on a rainy night/ Sad to miss the past
mother/ with the mouth chewing rice and removing fish bone”. Although the mother passed away,
the child still kept deep memories of her in his mind. The mother’s boundless love and her
lullabies have brought moral philosophy that we are unable to understand: “All our life has passed,
The study of human body in Nguyen Duy’s poetry
33
but we haven’t understood all mother’s lullabies”. The origin of the flesh in Nguyen Duy’s poetry
is not only linked to the image of the mother but also the image of grandmother who left an
unforgettable impression on the subject’s mind. He said: “I don’t know how hard my grandma’s
life is/ she caught crabs and small shrimps in Quan paddy field/ she carried green tea in Ba Trai/
In the porridge stall walked she at cold nights!” (The Len Ferry). On the first lines, the character
“I” told readers about naughty games in his childhood to put more highlight on the difficult life,
which the grandmother suffered without any complaints to bring him up. “I” grew up in his
grandma’s generous love and silence, so when becoming mature, his soul was full of sorrows
while recalling the past. It is the reason why the boundary between grandmother and the God has
been faded in the character’s mind: “I’m staying between the imagination and the reality/ between
my grandmother and the God/ The time in hunger with undercooked arrow-roots/ Still felt the
scent of white tuberose mixed with incense smoke”. The simple way of expressing the carefulness
through the image “undercooked arrow-roots” becomes so sacred and sweet. Especially, the
image of the grandmother has become everlasting in his soul when: “American bombs damaged
my grandma’s house/ Song Temple and all other pagodas/ Where left the Gods and the Saints for/
the grandma sold eggs in Len gas station”. Not only the bombs caused the damage on houses but
the gods and saints also left. However, the grandmother was still there to struggle against it. The
last image of the grandmother “soldeggs in Len gas station” was such a deep impression in the
subject’s mind. His sorrow was doubled when he came back home then saw his grandmother’s
gravestone cover under the grass. He shouted: “After a long time in the army came I back home/
the river still differs on both sides/ Too late is it for me to show my love to the grandma/ Now lied
her flesh under the grass”. The body of the grandmother and the mother as the source of the flesh
gave the subject “I” the body and working hard to get nurture the flesh” with worries. However,
now they go to the nirvana and their body is simply under the grave. In other words, when the
flesh of beloved people can’t exist, it’s impossible for them to continue their life’s meaning,
which can be shown through the existence of children and younger generations who remember
their origin of their body and life. It seems to show the gratitude to the ancestors and the homeland
as the origin of birth, Nguyen Duy was willing to be an ordinary and miserable individual:
“Regardless of looking untidy/ looking forwards to some lines of poem/ In the crowds determined
I that I would be nothing”, “To be the wine for the public to enjoy/ And for myself to be drunk”
(The poem of subsidy period).
The source of human body in Nguyen Duy’s poetry shows a deep gratitude as well as great
love to the nature and the homeland with ordinary people who created the body of the subject “I”.
The obsession about the origin of the body in Nguyen Duy’s poetry is also shown through the
awareness of the role and responsibility of human existence in the society or community.
Therefore, it creates “personal identity” and